Thursday, 19 November 2026

The Council Rent Setting Shenanigans Part 2

Thursday 19/11/2026

I've had a reply from Rhun's office and it's this. Unfortunately I have to screenshot it in sections. Sorry for the blurred image.


So I asked google does the CPI include rents of Private Landlords and this was the reply.


What relevance the CPI has for Social Housing is totally baffling to me, especially when they use Private Landlord rent increases to arrive at their total figure. You will also note there is no mention in the reply of the difference in % rent increases over time v JSA increases as if that part of the blog did not exist. Neither do they wish to comment as to whether Rhun considers. Having one rule for Council Tenants and another rule for Leaseholders, is something his office should comment on, be concerned over, or actively take measures to stop. Outside of me once again emailing the Local Government Ombudsman. In order to stop the 'Criminal Negligence' from continuing. 

'If only you were First Minister eh Crazydave' It would be a telephone call to the LGO asking 'Are you aware of this disparity?' and 'Now that you are. What the hell are you going to do about it?'. But no it's fob off, and wash his hands of any responsibility. I wonder if any of Rhun's constituents live in similar circumstances?

Am I to Picky? So once again seeing as people need reminding. Council Housing is supposed to be a non-profit organisation. Well they sure are profiting out of this property compared to a 3 bedroom house. And they are using a CPI that bears no relevance what so ever, to the running cost of any Council property. 

What have they done for you lately Crazydave? Jack S mate other than have a gas engineer turn up, rob me of some gardening tools, that he denies but I know the truth. And ruined the gas fire in the lounge while he was at it. The combined actions were nothing more than hate crime carried out by that employee. That they had a contractor to fix, and that was a nightmare to get an appointment date right. And fix a toilet cistern that had exploded. Now that was good customer service. A Sunday emergency call out. I only wish he'd used a pipe cutter to cut the thread on one pipe, rather than bend the pipe he needed fitting it to, as I'm OCD about straight lines, versus bendy one's. But the toilet was back useable again. If not artistically pleasing.

Meanwhile they eagerly take the rent monies, for slum housing above and beyond what someone is given by the state to survive on per week. And it seems the Plaid Government at Cardiff Bay considers this an acceptable state of affairs. It really isn't though is it Prime Minister/First Minister. Bricks and mortar worth more than a human life?

So the question has to be asked. 'Why hasn't JSA increased by the same CPI rate as council rentals?' Is it Westminster's institutionalised discrimination toward Benefit Claimants. The kind Kemi Badenock repeatedly engages in during PMQ's? With her 'Cut the benefits budget' mantra. 

Today 20/11/2026 while I'm doing this re-write on BBC5Live today they had some fella on saying how the '£350Billion Benefit budget was unsustainable'. Where do they think this money is going? It's going to Private landlords, it's going to Councils and Housing Associations, it's going to the gas companies the electricity companies and it's going to the Supermarkets, ie It's all going back into the economy supporting those in employment. If they wanted more work places for the 16-24yr old's maybe they could return the pension age to 65, how many job places would that open up? 

AI tells me. 


So if you want to create 55,000 job's for young people reverse the pension age back to 65.

I'll say again. These rentals could be reduced by 50% saving government umpteen £Billions in the Housing Benefit Budget. Yet none of you are willing to say 'Let's see if we can'. And investigate the claim, you know the full audit like HMRC would engage in with a Corporation. But nope it's likely to be. 'We've got this method and were sticking to it, even though it's obviously flawed'. As you must believe bricks and mortar are worth more than people. And not just Council's but Housing Associations as well, as they are no doubt using the same method to increase their profitability.

So I replied to one of Rhun's latest tweets.


It's worth noting that the Council claim they are using the Joseph Rowntree method to arrive at their new increased rents, while the Plaid Government are telling me it's the CPI that is used to decide the % increase. Or is the Rowntree method simple use the CPI as a means of inflating the rents, way and above what they are worth?




  







Friday, 23 October 2026

Prime Minister First Minister I Give you the Council Rent setting Survey 2027/2028

Hello Prime Minister First Minister                                         Todays date 23/10/2026

I've recently received Cardiff County Councils, 'Council Rent Setting Survey 2027/2028'. I should really scan the introductory letter in full but time is pressing and the library isn't just around the corner. So for now I'll just quote paragraphs of interest I'm sure both of you will know this but the casual reader will not.

Para 2: The amount that council rents can be increased by is set by Welsh Government. A decision has not yet been made about how much this will be from next April.

Para 3: Each year we check that our rents are affordable using the Joseph Rowntree Foundation living rents test. Council rent are also much lower than private rents, as shown below.

This is a foto of the compare private v council rents in the letter.

In the summer of 1999 when I first moved here the rent was this amount.


Google tells me: A rise from £46.79 to £124.22 means the final value is about 2.65 times the original, which corresponds to a 165.4% increase. using this calculation 

Calculation

  • Difference: £124.22 − £46.79 = £77.43
  • Percentage increase:
77.4346.79×100≈165.4%

Meanwhile during the same period Job Seekers Allowance Google gives me these figures: In 1999 the weekly Jobseeker’s Allowance personal allowance was £40.70 for people aged 18–24 and £51.40 for people aged 25 or over, the same for both contribution‑based and income‑based JSA.

and for 2026: The current New Style Jobseeker’s Allowance rate in 2026 is £75.65 a week if you’re under 25 and £95.55 a week if you’re 25 or over, correct as of October 2026.

Google tells me: The increase from £51.40 to £95.55 is about 85.97%.

Can either of you gentlemen tell me how it is morally justifiable for rents to increase by 165.4% yet the amount you give people to live on has only risen by 85% over the last 27yrs. It isn't is it gents? As for this Joseph Rowntree Foundation living rents test, that must be one bogus test if you ask me.

I started raising concerns about % rent increases from the year 2000. I am a tenant of a ground floor flat in a former 3 bedroom council property. Unfortunately for me the tenant in the first floor flat is a leaseholder, and I will come back to that later on. But if he were not the combined rent for this woefully inadequate conversion would be £248.44 compared to a 3 bedroom property £162.46 an £85.98 per week increase or x 52 weeks of the year means a £4,470.96 increase on what they would have gotten if not converted.

It is one of the reasons I created these 2 banners and displayed it outside the Welsh Assembly Building during it's early years. Not that Rhodri Morgan or Carwyn Jones gave a rats arse for the contents, maybe just maybe you 2 gents might be different?


In this instance Council employees. And this one.


I'm sure if I was scamming the DWP for £4,470.96 a year they'd be wanting to jail me, but for councils it's all tickety boo no problemo here's your dosh. Given that over 80% of all council tenants are in receipt of Housing Benefit.

So what are we as tenants getting for this 165.4% rent increase,  the self same criminal negligence that I endured in the first 2 yrs of this tenancy. Culminating in this reply to a complaint from me dated 9/6/2025 by one N Ibrahim. (I've procrastinated on the full blog post reply to N. Ibrahim I hope to remedy that soon).

''Regarding noise disturbance from the neighbouring flat, I understand your client’s concerns and the effect this may have on his health. However, as 15A XXX is a leasehold property, the Council does not have authority to enforce the type of flooring used within the premises''.

All first floor council tenants are required to be carpeted throughout with quality underlay. Never has the tenant above ever had that either prior to his becoming a leaseholder or since. That Cardiff County Council never had the same stipulation as ordinary tenants in their leaseholder contract, was and is Criminally Negligent of them and I have suffered a detriment that no other regular tenants have to endure since 2001 when he first moved here. His lounge is laminate flooring and the rest is bare chip board. The complaint was due to him getting a kitten and it running the hell everywhere, I'm certain that it would have pissed off anyone not just me.

That the council employee could write such tripe, is an example of their total lack of  care for this or any other tenant. And I hope that this blog post will rectify this glaring error on the Councils part. And that Wales's First Minister will contact the Local Government Ombudsman to bring the claim against Cardiff County Council of Criminal Negligence for this omission on my behalf.

I was heartened to hear in PMQ's this week that the labour Party is looking into Standing Charges Mr Burnham. They were the reason I painted this banner.

In a typical HMO you can have anywhere from 5 to 10 so called flats sub-divide into  one former house, with 5-10 standing charges for gas, electricity, water, TV Licenses. People don't end up in these properties because they are wealthy, generally they are the poorest members of society yet pro rata they pay more than the wealthiest in these charges. I being a low usage user can often see my Standing charge for electric being higher than my usage charge. And at this tenancy they get double what they would if it was declared a shared house. 

I asked Rhodri Morgan why not divide the standing charge between the tenants of these former homes, as the juice all comes in on the same line but is sub-divided once inside the property. Yes there are more meters but still, the vulnerable are indeed cash cows for these companies, as well as for the Council/Housing Association/Private Landlord.

Thatcher thought that the free market would mean cheaper rents, she never counted on the banks just nodding through jacked up prices of those on the property market. I mean why would they deny the new inflated rate of house prices, as they stood to gain greater revenues in terms of mortgage repayments. So the buy to let property market boomed and the price of rents increased to cover the re-evaluated property cost.

Your happy to pay private landlord £207.00 per week for slum housing, no questions asked, yet bitch about paying JSA at £95.55.. Who is the real drain on society here gents? And the private landlords never have to live in fear of being 'Sanctioned' by the DWP to collect their 'Benefit'. 

So we are in a situation where google tells me: The UK government’s forecast housing benefit budget for 2025–26 is £37.3 billion, according to official DWP expenditure tables.

All going to a professional elite be they Council, Housing Association or private landlords. 

Tell me gents have Council employee wages risen by 165.4% over the last 27 yrs? So then why have the rents been allowed to? No scrutiny is why. So all things being equal if there's a 3.5% rent increase this coming year in council rents or rents across the board it will mean.

Google says: 3.5% of £37.3 billion is £1.3055 billion. So the estimate for 2027 will be £38.65Billion in Housing Benefit. Nice work if you can get it eh gents?

How about a rent freeze for the next 10 yrs hmm? Or praise the Lord cutting council rents by 50% to reduce 'The Benefits budget' as the MSM like to harp on about. Maybe then they wont all need to endlessly bitch about 'The Triple Lock' for pensioners, because you will have more than enough to cover it from this saving.

Personally I would compulsory purchase any private landlord property where over 50% of tenants are in receipt of housing benefit, and no I would not be paying them the going rate for the property. It would be 'How much have you paid off the mortgage? Minus all the HB they have received for it' and renegotiate a deal with the banks, or maybe someone can come up with a better solution? As I am rather radical on these things. As after all many of these private landlord HMO's properties 100% of the mortgage is being paid for by the government plus profit to the landlord.

Had the Council housed me in the upstairs flat, at that time I would not have been able to afford to carpet the flat throughout, or pay for quality underlay. As it is my flat is covered with rugs that I have found thrown out, and off cuts of carpet I have also picked up in the streets. So are new tenants offered financial assistance to cover this stipulation, that they don't have to pay back via weekly deductions from their meagre benefits? Or should the council be doing it on the tenants behalf?

The First Minister refused to respond to my questioning on e-bike law in Wales. I hope you Mr Burnham will have a read, and maybe some sanity be brought to that area as well. You will find links to those on the side panel of this blog post.

And here is a link to my early blogpost not found on this one, click on the green letters and it will open in a new tab. WELSH ASSEMBLY GOVERNMENT THE CRAZYDAVE FILES

And as a gift to end the blog post one of my paintings. The full title is: Another Bankster bites the dust 2015. (Acrylic on MDF)

Here is the accountability section of this blog. I sent an email to both my home address was supplied but hidden here for privacy reasons.

andy.burnham.mp@parliament.uk rhun.apiorwerth@senedd.wales 26/10/2026 14.36hrs

Hello Prime Minister, First Minister
Here is a link to my latest blogpost on the scandal that is Council Rents. It's a reply to the Council Rent Setting Survey for 2027/2028. It asks 'Is it morally justifiable that council rents have increased by 165.4% in the last 27yrs, while JSA has only increased by 85.97% during the same period?'. It also deals with the Criminal Negligence of the Council in not stipulating the same standards for Leaseholders as that of ordinary tenants. And that I have been living under a detriment that vast majority of ground floor tenants do not, for the last 25yrs. 
I trust you will take timeout to read it and hopefully take action, because this rent increase obviously isn't justifiable, is it?

Yours David Gabriel

I did have an automatic reply from Rhun's email, telling me that if this is First Minister business email at this address. Obviously they hadn't proof read the automated reply, because there's another one with a full stop after prif.

 I also tweeted them on X.


It's odd that the link to the blogpost didn't show up? So while I was at it I thought I'd get onto the Welsh Media here in Wales once again. With this tweet.


Because frankly, I don't believe anyone at Wales Online or BBC Wales Politics will be interviewing Rhun on this topic. And that Ladies and Gents is it from me today. Sorry about the formatting, weird things happen when you copy paste on here. But the motto 'What more would you do, if it didn't need to be perfect?' runs deep in my veins. 

Thursday 29/10/2026

I listened to the coverage of the Budget on BBC 5 Live, and was tickled by Matt Chorley's interview with a female private landlord, who was bitching about a hike in tax. 

So today I thought I'd tweet Matt this, I guess I should be sending an email to Mr Healey but maybe just maybe Mr Burnham will be asking him the same questions as me? Can we hear ''National Scandal'' in the headlines? With ''Councils and Housing Associations have been playing the system for decades''. Anyway the tweet.


Yep all the while her living the life of luxury tenant has to somehow manage on £95 quid a week. At least that is the way MSM like to portray life for benefit claimants, especially the likes of Kemi Badenoch. ''£207 quid a week for you cos you're rich, and £95 quid a week for you cos you're poor''. 'A Just and Equitable Society?' I think not.

Whose to blame? Why those in government who else? Or is it 'We The People' For not holding the Political Elite to proper scrutiny, year in year out. Especially our local councils.

And yesterday 2 miracles happened, I kid you not. Two separate emails from Rhun's office employees with two different reference numbers. I didn't get any of that to my e-bike emails. I'll have to email them both together and ask ''Can I just deal with one of you please? Ta''. But not today. 

And seeing as they are banned at the Senedd I thought I'd give @GBNews a shout out.


Oh the tweet hasn't shown in the screen shot. Let's do the easier version.


There much better.

Monday the 2/11/2026 update.
I sent this email to John Healey unfortunately I sent it to this address john.healey.mp@parliament.uk I had a automated reply back saying that. ''If it was for Chancellor business I'd have to fill in some online form''. Well that ain't going to happen. Cant your email reader just forward it to the 'I handle Chancellor business correspondence' person, a 20 second job. Rather than expecting contactors to fill out an online form? The email included the one sent to the PM n FM.

Hello Chancellor
Below is an email I sent to the Prime Minister and the First Minister of the Senedd. With a link to a blogpost of mine that deals with the ever-increasing council rents v JSA. I hope you discuss its contents with the Prime Minister. I know that you are under pressure from all angles to cut the Benefits budget. I would really like you to consider, cutting Council and Housing Association rents by 50%. 
I also hope that you will come to the same conclusion as me, that the rise in rents compared to JSA is not 'morally justifiable'. 
As for 'Is it good value for money?' My reply would be ''Are you having a laugh''.
Yours David Gabriel.

And to the two ladies who replied on behalf of The First Minister. Why oh why do they have to start their emails in Welsh when only 27.3% of the population can read Welsh is frankly baffling. Another alienate the majority for an ideological policy. So here is another 'Money saving policy' from Crazydave. How about we have a 'Opt In' system in Wales for those wishing to have their correspondence in Welsh. And until they do that, all they will get is the English version. Question FM 'How much would that policy save across all sections of government in Wales?' As I've heard of people getting 15 pages of documents from the courts in English, then 15 pages more in Welsh. Unadulterated waste of taxpayers money, just to make a minority feel somehow relevant/superior.

So this to the two ladies: 
Hi Ladies 
You both replied to me on the same day, with reference numbers for my email to Rhun and Andy Burnham. I wonder if you could have a chat between yourselves, and decide who should do the replying. That way I won't have any mixed messaging, and thank you both for being prompt in replying.
Thanks David Gabriel.

That's it for today.

Thurs 5/11/2026 
I sent John Healey the following tweet, well it is ludicrous isn't it people?


Today Monday the 9/11/2026
I sent an email to the 4 main opposition leaders down the Senedd. 

Hello Everyone
Below is an email sent to the Prime Minister and The First Minister regarding the setting of Council Rents, which I understand will be up for review shortly by the Senedd.
I trust that you will all read the blogpost from the link provided in that email, and come to the same conclusion that I have. That these increases in Council rent levels are not 'Morally Justifiable'. And do what you can to end the Joseph Rowntree living rent formula that Councils use to justify these annual increases.
Yours with thanks
David Gabriel

Weds 11/11/2026 update

I had 2 automatic replies this one from Anthony Slaughter leader of the Greens in Wales kinda baffled me. 

Who sends an email to an inbox that is not actively managed? Nobody is the correct answer. The other reply was from Jane Dodds leader of the Lib Dems, and it had this message.

Jane it's easier to send one email to 4 people than it is to send 4 emails individually in order for you to reply directly. It's as if between The Chancellor and Assembly Members, that all sorts of barriers are created in order to not deal with stuff. Now it's time to contact the opposition party leaders at Westminster. What are the odds on them having similar messages in their replies. Helen and Darren are yet to reply.

So I've sent virtually the same email to these leaders of various opposition parties at Westminster.

Hello Everyone
Below is an email sent to the Prime Minister and The First Minister regarding the setting of Council Rents, which I understand will be up for review shortly by the Senedd, and I presume at Westminster as well.
I trust that you will all read the blogpost from the link provided in that email, and come to the same conclusion that I have. That these increases in Council rent levels are not 'Morally Justifiable'. And do what you can to end the Joseph Rowntree living rent formula that Councils use to justify these annual increases.
Yours with thanks
David Gabriel

Thurs 19/11/2026 

I thought I had better come clean at this moment my actual rent per week is £121.95 I just used the council one above cos frankly it saved me rummaging through my files. What it means in terms of  % increase and overall gain for the council per week from renting it out as 2 x 1 bedroom flats is as follows. x2 the weekly rent would be £243.90 as opposed to the £162.46 for a 3 bedroom house a gain of £81.44 per week and a gain of £4,234.88 for the year over a 3 bedroom property. In terms of the % rent increase since 1999 it means it's a 160.6% increase. Not the 165.4% as shown previously. It's still a hell of a lot more than JSA has increased by.

Oh and the Community charge was £7.28 pw is now £30.04 a 312.8% increase and remember they are getting 2 x that here so £60.08 pw. And nobody cares about that fraud either given that I am in receipt of Council Tax benefit, what with being a pensioner. 

£60.08 x 52 = £3,124.16 Nice work if you can get it eh? Houses of multiple occupancy sure are a cash cows to the professional elite. And to hell with the tenants. So there, my conscience is now clear, but the fundamental question of 'How is this increase in rents v JSA morally justifiable' remains. Especially in light that this council does everything in it's power to 'criminally neglect it's tenants'. When I finally do get around to completing the N. Ibrahim blog you will see what I mean.